AuchanNingboXinxingRoadStoreProjectPhase歐尚寧波店二期工TenderEvaluation SteelStructureThe:NingboImmochanRealEstateCo.,業主：寧波置PM:ShanghaiUManConstructionProjectManagementCo.,

Date:August8th,歐尚寧波店二期鋼結構工程授標評估推薦報TenderEvaluationand mendationReportOfSteelStructureWorkForAuchanNingboXinxingRoadStoreNingboImmochanRealEstate 寧波置業AuchanHypermarketNingboXinxingRoadStoreisasupermarketinvestedbyNingboImmochanRealEstateCo. .TheprojectlandlocatedatthecrossofHuanChengWestRoadandXinxingRoadinNingbo.Thelandareais67,685m2.Thefoundationistubularpilefoundation.Thetotalbuildingareaisabout179,589m2.Thewholeprojectisdividedintotwophases.Thebuild-upareaforthefirstphaseisabout52,135m2,including34,135m2abovegroundandthebasementisabout18,000m2.Andthesecondphaseisabout127,724.36m2,including74,166.74m2abovegroundandthebasementisabout53,557.61m2.ThebasementflooronPhaseⅡisdesignedforparkinggarageandmachineroom.1F、2Fisdesignedforsmallshopsandanchorstores.2Fisdesignedforsupermarketsandfreshareas.Thepartof3F、4Fiscatering.ThescopeofthisTenderistheSteelStructure.Referringtoconstructiondrawingsandrelevanttendering 路路口新建一大型超市，總占地面積67,685m2，約101.5畝，基礎層屋面是停車場；本次招標范圍為歐尚寧波店二期鋼結構工程，詳見設計工程圖和有關招標文件。tenderingcourseThetenderinvitationletterwasreleasedonMay.30th,2013tothosethreecandidateswhopasstheprequalification,asfollowing:BuildingTechniqueGroupCo., (hereinafterreferredtoasthe“CBTGC”),JiangsuChanghongSteelStructureEngineeringCo., (hereinafterreferredtoasthe"Changhong"),JiashanZhongjianSteelStructureEngineeringCo. .(hereinafterreferredtoasthe"Jiashan2013年5月30日向通過投標資格預審的中國建筑技術（以下簡稱“中技、江蘇鋼結構工程（以下簡稱“常虹、嘉善中建鋼結構安裝（以下簡稱“嘉善中建）三家單位了投標邀請函。 sanddrawingswerereleasedonMay.30thof2013年5月30日了招標文件和招標圖紙Uman bidforfamiliesraisethequestionthereplyonJune.4thof20132013年6月4日，管理公司對各家投標疑問進行了回復Theadditional sanddrawingswerereleasedonJune.7thof2013andopenedinwitnessbyAuchan’sprojectmanagerAuchanheadquarterconferenceroomonJune.13thof2013年6月7日，收到上述三家投標單位返回的第一輪投標文件，并于6月13日在歐尚項目經理的下在歐尚總部會議室進行開標 sanddrawingswerereleasedonJune.24thof2013年6月24日，管理公司向各家投標單位澄清文件Theadditionaltender sanddrawingswerereleasedonJune.26thof2013andopenedinwitnessbyAuchan’sprojectmanageratAuchanheadquarterconferenceroomonJune.28thof2013.2013年6月26日，收到上述三家投標單位返回的第二輪投標文件，并于6月28日在歐尚項目經理的下在歐尚總部會議室進行開標 sanddrawingswerereleasedonJuly.15thof2013年7月15日，管理公司向各家投標單位補充范圍和報價要求Theadditional sanddrawingswerereleasedonJuly.26thof2013andopenedinwitnessbyAuchan’sprojectmanagerAuchanheadquarterconferenceroomonJuly.29thofJiashanZhongjian（Thetenderwithlowestpriceofthirdroundbidder）providethepreferentialpriceaboutthisbiddingonAug5th2013.2013年8月5日,第三輪報價最低投標單位嘉善中建鋼構，提供了關于鋼結構（不包括幕墻龍骨鋼構）的價。UManorganizedthetenderevaluationandprovidesthetenderevaluationreportbaseonallthefirstcommercial/technicaltendersandinterviewresultsonAug.8th201388commercialtender歐尚寧波店鋼結構工程的投標報價匯總詳見下表Thetenderquotationsarecollectedasthefollowing Listofthelandscape unitprice:項———————————————————— JiashanZhongjian（Thetenderwithlowestpriceofthirdroundbidder）providethepreferentialpriceaboutthisbiddingonAug.5th嘉善中建鋼構2013年8月5日,報價最低投標單位嘉善中建鋼構，提供了關于鋼結構（不包括幕墻龍骨鋼構） 價：2,120萬元Seenfromtheabovesummarytablecanbe:July29,2013backtothestandard,thereisabiggapbetweenthebiddingprice,thepricefromlowtohighorder:JiashanZhongjian<Changhong<CBTGC,betweenthehighestandlowestquotationpricegapofabout1076,572yuan.Basedonthedetailedprojecttoprovidethelistofysisthat,theunitsaretheexistenceofindividualunitpricehigh,CBTGCoffersthehighest,thatintheNingboareaofthetechnicallevelandthemanagementlevelofhighercostofsteelworks,theunitpricehasexceededtheprojectbudgetandinternalcontrol;Changhong,Zhongjianofferrelatively從上面匯總表中可以看出：2013年7月29日的回標中，各投標單位的報價存在一定差距，其報價從低到高依次為：嘉善中建<<中技，最高報價與最低報價之間的差距約達1,076,572元。根據對各投標人提供的詳細工程量進行分析可以得知，中技的報價最高，說明這家企業在鋼結構方面技術水平和經營管理水平成本較高；而、嘉善中建報價相對比較合理。Therecord,scoringandevaluationofthe開標記錄及報價打分 --江蘇鋼結構--Fromthebusiness ysis,threetenderersreasonableorderis:Changhong>JiashanZhongjian>從商務標分析來看，三家投標單位比較合理的順序依次是：>嘉善中建>中技三、technicalproposalThetenderfortheSteelStructureprojectbidding,thetechnicalstandardhavetheirprosandcons,butconsistentwiththerequirementsofconstruction,fromthetechnicalscheme,technologicalschemeofJiashanZhongjianexpressionisbetterthantheChanghong,CBTGCinthewhole,whichingrouptechnologyaredescribedemphaticallyandideasfromthecharacteristicsofdifficultandprojectthequalityassurancesystem,alsoveryperfect;本次招標為二期鋼結構，各家的技術標各有優劣，但都基本符合施工要求，從技術方案來看，嘉善中建技術標比較完善，對本項ThreetenderersreasonabletechnicalstandardorderisJiashanZhongjian>Changhong三家投標單位的技術標比較合理的順序依次是嘉善中建>>中技Thesubmissionsandinterviewresultsareas1JiashanMethodstatement:Constructionschemeofstrongpertinence,organizationalstructureand nelarrangementmoreSchedule:Goodteamapproachtimeschedule, Organizationchart:reasonableorganizationchart;Keystaffofmanagement:projectmanagerandallnelpresent,Projectmanager'sexperiencewithsimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis2MethodMethodstatement:Theconstructionschemeisreasonable,theprocessofclearthinkingMethodstatement:Theconstructionschemeisreasonable,theprocessofclearthinkingSchedule:Tomeetthebasicrequirements,schedulecontrolismoregeneral,notOrganizationchart:reasonableorganizationKeystaffofmanagement:projectmanagerand nelpresent,Projectmanager'sexperiencewithsimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis3Methodstatement:Theconstructionschemeisfeasible;butinthepertinenceisnotSchedule:Thebasicrequirements,the nisnotenoughdetailedandOrganizationchart:reasonableorganizationKeystaffofmanagement:projectmanagerand nelpresent,Projectmanager'sexperiencewithsimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisBasedon ysisresultsofcommercialandtechnicalsubmission,thetwoturn sweremarkedas結合商務標和技術標的分析結果，對各投標單位的兩輪投標文件進行綜合打分，其結果如下FormatandLogooftechnicalbiddingEXCELTheoveralldescriptionoftechnicalnTherationalityoftechnicalTheintegralityoftechnicalThepertinenceoftechnicalTherationalityoftechnicalTherationalityofdisposalTemporarypowerTemporarywaterRationalityofconstructionThematerialon-siteTheguaranteemeasureforprojectTheguaranteemeasureforconstructionqualityTheguaranteemeasureforconstructingsafetyandTheenvironmentprotectionTheequipmentnforconstructionandinstallation1.設備；2.人材機單價表Labor；Organizationandmanagementar