B2U4StageandScreenDevelopingideas《駱駝祥子》《紅樓夢》《京華煙云》LeadinginHaveyoureadanyofthesebooks?HaveyoueverseenthemoviesorTVplaysbasedonthesebooks?Whatdoyouthinkofthem?《了不起的蓋茨比》《伊利亞特》《夏洛克·福爾摩斯》Readthepassageandsummarisethemainideaofeachparagraphwithkeywords.ReadingAlltoooften,greatwordsendupbeingturnedintocinematic“turkeys”.Para.1:goodbookbadmoviesturkey:[C](informal)afailureReadthepassageandsummarisethemainideaofeachparagraphwithkeywords.ReadingPara.1:goodbookbadmoviesPara.2:examplesReadthepassageandsummarisethemainideaofeachparagraphwithkeywords.ReadingPara.1:goodbookbadmoviesPara.2:examples...Thismeansthatgreatbookscanloseplotdetailsandcharacterswhentheymovetothebigscreen.Para.3:reason1:lostdetailsReadthepassageandsummarisethemainideaofeachparagraphwithkeywords.ReadingPara1.goodbookbadmoviesPara2.examplesMoviesalsodisappointuswhenthingsdon’tlookthewayweimaginedtheminthebooks.Para3:reason1:lostdetailsPara.4:reason2:unrealizedimaginationReadthepassageandsummarisethemainideaofeachparagraphwithkeywords.ReadingPara1.goodbookbadmoviesPara2.examplesPara3:reason1:lostdetailsPara.4:reason2:unrealizedimaginationPara.5:commentsThereareathousandHamletsinathousandpeople’seyes.Perhapsweshouldjudgemoviesinitsownright.Matchtheauthor’sopinionsaboutthemovieadaptationstotheexamplesfromthepassage.(P60,A3)ReadingaecdbThisissomethingthateventhehighlysuccessfulHarryPotter

moviescan'tescapefrom,withfansofthebooksdisappointednottoseesomeoftheirfavouritecharactersinthemovieversions.Take,forexample,theepicmovieTroy,whichisinpartbasedonHomer’sTheIliad...ThemostquestionableissuewastheactresschosentoplaythepartofHelen.Manypeoplethoughtshedidn’tliveuptoHelen'stitleof"themostbeautifulwomanintheworld...Ifso,whyhasoneoftheearliestandgreatestworksinWesternstorytelling,Homer’sTheOdyssey,neverhadanequallygreatmoviebasedonit?Moviesofcourseneedimpressiveimages,sowhyhasAliceinWonderlandonlyresultedinmoviesbestdescribedas“interesting”?Moviesneedstrongcharacters.SowhyhavethemoviesbasedonTheGreatGatsby

neverbeenpraisedas“great”?Useexamplesinargumentativeessays.ReadingPara.1-2:goodbookbadmoviesPara3:reason1:lostdetailsPara.4:reason2:unrealizedimaginationPara.5:commentsTheOdysseyTheGreatGatsbyAliceinWonderlandHarryPotterTheIliadSherlockMadMenTheGreatGatsby1.Whydoestheauthorrepeatsaying“goodmoviesneed…,sowhy?”SharingToemphasizethatnomatterhowgoodthebooksare(goodstories,strongcha